PINETOP-LAKESIDE – White Mountain Democrats voted unanimously January 9 to oppose creating a new Sitgreaves County from the southern portions of Apache and Navajo Counties.

To consider the issue, Democrats looked at the taxes for the apartment occupied by Jesse Valencia, the proponent of the new county.

The condo in The Pines south of Show Low pays $534.80 in property taxes per year, but only $41.85 of that amount is allocated to Navajo County, according to official records. Most of the property tax payment goes to Blue Ridge schools and Timber Mesa Fire and Medical.

“If he wants to use that $41.85 to set up a new county and expects to have a lot of money left over for lowering taxes, he’s not looking at it correctly,” said Eric Kramer, Navajo County Democratic Chairman.

Participants at the meeting pointed out some of the costs of setting up a new sheriff’s department, including vehicles, radios, guns, handcuffs, salaries, a jail, etc. When all the departments of county government are considered, the cost would go far beyond the $41.85 in taxes paid for this dwelling as well as other homes in the proposed county.

Valencia was scheduled to speak at the meeting at the Pinetop-Lakeside Town Hall, but was a no-show.

“The movement complains about taxation without representation, but Valencia’s neighborhood is represented by Steve Williams, who is an exceptionally hard-working and capable public servant — though a Republican,” Kramer said.

Navajo County actually spends no off-reservation property tax money on the reservations,” Kramer said. “The county gets money from multiple sources, including sales taxes and gasoline taxes. Reservation residents pay these taxes and are included as county residents in the formulas for distribution of this money from the state to the counties.”

“The concern that three of the five members of the Board of Supervisors are Native Americans is unfounded, particularly in the case of Jesse Thompson and Dawnafe Whitesinger,” he added. “Whitesinger lives in Pinetop-Lakeside and Thompson has a strong relationship with Winslow. Trying to remove them from political influence strictly on the basis of race would violate the Arizona Constitution, the U.S. Constitution and the Voting Rights Act. It would give the county and state a bad name and result in costly and losing litigation.”

“Though voters narrowly rejected the proposed jail district, we need to figure out a way to support the two counties we have to maintain our deputies and other essential county services,” Kramer said.

Reach the editor at

(5) comments


Thank you for pointing out what many others have attemptedto explain to this group.
Plus add the no wiggle on the moving of county seat to Show low. No concern for the costs.

Our Arizona public resources can be put to a much better use by exposing and ending the local corruption. Which if ended would no longer need a county split. As the laws of the state would then after be followed.


Um Mr. Kramer would man power and equipment be considered spending money? Maybe you missed that somewhere or it was not revealed to you. Just sayin.


Manpower and equipment would both cost money. When Navajo County puts people and equipment on the reservations, it uses funding sources other than off-reservation property taxes.


Interesteing at how the publisher of WMI is also the Democratic Chair person. Biased much?

It is a laugh to insinuate the reservation pays their fair share in taxes.

The county seat for Navajo County would remain as would the seat for Apache County. Show Low would become the new seat for Sitgreaves County as it is the hub of the white mountains anyways. The tax base from sales and property taxes would more than enough support this new county.


Russ, I am not sure you will comprehend this, but I will try. You do understand that more than one person can have the same last name? So no the publisher of the WMI is NOT the same person as the Navajo Democratic Chair.
I am not sure you understand what the start up costs would be for a new county to establish a new sheriff department with officers, equipment, vehicles, staff as well as the new jail to be built and staffed. Plus all the other offices, Treasurer, Assessor, Recorder, Superior court, etc.
You might also review the Wikipedia article regarding the formation of La Pas county in 1983 and how it had to depend on state money to get established. It also mentions how the rules have been changed to make new counties more difficult.,_Arizona

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.