ST. JOHNS—Since November, 2018, Tommy Siqueiro III who was once the director of the Haven Health care facility in Show Low, has faced charges in Apache County alleging child prostitution, sexual exploitation of minors and sex crimes relating to minors in two different court files. He was accused of meeting two underaged females in a hotel room in Springerville on July 5, 2017 and recording, then distributing the encounters. He admitted his guilt in open court on February, 2020 and was sentenced May 7.

Tommy Siqueiro III

Tommy Siqueiro III, who formerly worked at Haven Health in Show Low, was arrested in the San Francisco Bay Area and held on a $15 million bond on several counts of child prostitution, sexual exploitation of a minor and sexual conduct with a minor.

After authorities completed their investigation in September, 2017, warrants issued for his arrest and Siqueiro was located in California in 2018. Law enforcement agents there arrested Siqueiro at a wedding when he went to his vehicle to retrieve something. Once he was transported to Apache County, he was formally charged on November 18, 2018 and has been custody in the Apache County jail on a $15 million cash bond ever since.

After unsuccessfully trying to have the case moved out of Apache County, a change of plea came on for a hearing on February 28, 2020, before visiting Judge Monica Stauffer from Greenlee County. Siqueiro is 37 years old, a small, fit man and was dressed in a navy blue jail-issue jump suit. The respective sides were represented by Deputy Apache County Attorney Joseph Young and defense counsel from Mesa, Dana Hogle. The defense claimed in court filings that the minors were actually call girls, and the website where Siqueiro found them advertised the escorts as being adults.

After a years-long discovery process and negotiations, the plea agreement called for Siqueiro to plead guilty to child prostitution and sexual exploitation of a minor, were Class 2 Felonies and a third charge from the second court file. The parties agreed that Siqueiro would serve 10 years in prison and once he gets out will be on supervised sex-offender probation for 20 years, which includes the requirement to register as a sex offender.

During the hearing, the mother of one of the victims gave an emotional statement. Her daughter was 15 years old when she encountered Siqueiro and the mother began noticing behavior changes in the child which the mother could not explain. She blames herself for “not protecting her daughter,” whose brain had not yet developed to process the event, the sobbing mother told the court.

For his part, Siqueiro wept while offering a “sincere apology.” He recounted a story he read which reflected on the “dash” on a gravestone between the year of birth and the year of death. Thus far, Siqueiro said, he regrets what he’s done during the time of life that the “dash” represents to him. He noted that his marriage was ruined, his kids estranged, but that he “was grateful for this experience because it helps me learn a lot about myself.” Prosecutor Young called him a narcissist which may have been apparent to anyone listening to Siqueiro’s remarks.

Judge Stauffer seemed confused about her role in the proceeding. Her first remark on taking the bench was “I don’t know what we’re doing,” and later said, “I’m just the settlement judge!” Instead of concluding the matter then, Siqueiro’s plea and sentencing was delayed for three months until May 7. Stauffer also, without explanation, ordered the court file “sealed,” so a check of court records reveal nothing about Siqueiro, as if these crimes had just never happened. Tommy Siqueiro III cannot appeal a judgment of guilt after a guilty plea. As of press time, he has not been transferred to the department of corrections; he is listed as an inmate in the county jail.

Reach the reporter at

(3) comments

Equine Fan

There is no legal justification for sealing these public records. The Independent should file a motion to gain access so that the public can remain informed. I say this as a retired state and federal prosecutor with over 25 years experience prosecuting many cases involving sexual offenses and crimes against children.


Should it have made any difference if the girls presented themselves as 18 years old?

Did they or did he assume that? Did the girls place an ad?


This case is a prime example of race discrimination in this country. Read the headlines from start to finish and you would have thought there were thousands of young children. So a police officer that blatantly kills George Floyd can have bail upgraded to 1.25M but a man that is merely "accused" (at the time) of supposed "heinous" crimes- has his bail set to 15M cash only?! Something isn't right. Visiting call girl or dating websites is not a crime. The problem in our society is people can lie about their age and not be held accountable for it. These websites do not properly police their end users. No-one forced these girls to signup, and I'm pretty sure with the amount of social media access, sexual exploitation and pressure to grow up quickly, they knew what their intentions were. These websites are designed to appeal visually. Some people look very young for their actual age and others much older and beyond their actual birth age. If someone lies and states they are of legal age, why is that not a crime? So a person can go obtain a false ID, lie their way into a bar, get into a DUI accident and not be held accountable?! Nope- its doesn't work that way. And it shouldn't in cases like this.

My gut tells me here there are police coverups, personal ties to law enforcement, the judicial system, and the printed media. There seems to be some copy and paste errors in your reporting and it's really unfortunate. Did this man make a mistake? Yes. Should he be serving 10-20 years? Absolutely not. If I were this man's family I would have this reopened and investigated for corruption and discrimination.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.