christine-flowers.jpg

It’s rare that a simple tweet triggers in me the desire to write a column.

On night three of the Republican National Convention last week, I had the great pleasure of watching Madison Cawthorne, a young paraplegic who is running for a house seat in North Carolina. At the very end of his short but moving address, this man – who is otherwise confined to a wheelchair – was helped out of that chair by two friends and stood.

He was standing for the flag, for what it represents, for his fellow citizens, for the president he supports, for his family, and as a symbolic gesture of how we are all able to transcend the most exceptional and challenging circumstances. Being paralyzed at the age of 20 clearly qualifies. Watching him struggle to stand up, and only imagining the effort it took to mobilize petrified muscle and sinew, I thought of the following lines from my father’s favorite poem, “Invictus:”

“In the fell clutch of circumstance/I have not winced nor cried aloud/Under the bludgeoning of chance/My head is bloody, but unbowed.”

I assumed that most people watching had the same reaction, even if their minds didn’t wander to a 145-year-old poem. I was wrong. Shortly after Cawthorne spoke, NPR correspondent Yamiche Alcindor tweeted the following:

“Madison Cawthorn made it a point to stand, suggesting that all Americans should stand during the Pledge of Allegiance & National Anthem. It was a direct rebuke of actions by ppl – including Black athletes who are currently sitting out games – protesting police brutality.”

The thing that angered me about Alcindor’s tweet was the fact that she presumed to delve into the mind of this courageous young man and find some negative, possibly sinister motive to his profoundly moving act of standing up.

Instead of simply admiring the effort it took for Madison Cawthorne to raise himself up and expose his disability to millions of viewers nationwide, this journalist decided to set him up as a foil to the men she obviously admired much more. Alcindor, without anything other than her own bias, decided that Cawthorne was attacking the Colin Kaepernick brigade, all of those “Black athletes who are currently sitting out games protesting police brutality.”

And that, I would suggest, is beneath contempt.

Those “Black athletes who are currently sitting” are able to stand up at leisure and walk to the nearest bank to cash their six- and seven-figure salaries, while Madison Cawthorne will never be able to walk anywhere, ever again.

It is also beneath contempt because this journalist of color is, in a not so veiled way, accusing a young disabled white man of showing disrespect to able-bodied Black men. How dare she use someone else’s misfortune to advance a political agenda, and do so in a way that is dishonestly veiled. After all, Alcindor can easily say that she wasn’t criticizing Cawthorne, she was just “suggesting” that this is what his action “suggested.” It’s a nice trick, one I’ve used myself. But I would never be so callous as to use it to shame a paraplegic to advance a political message.

You might disagree that this is what Alcindor was doing. You might think that it was legitimate, and that Cawthorne opened himself to such attacks because he let himself be “used” by the GOP at the convention, allowed himself to be trotted out as some symbol of “Trump love for country.” I actually heard that said.

Far be it from me to try and disabuse you of the notion that every time someone shows a moment of courage and allows us a glimpse into their soul, it’s inauthentic and programmed (particularly if they support President Trump).

If you are that type of person, you were already clicking “like” on Alcindor’s tweet before Madison Cawthorne had a chance to sit back down in his wheelchair.

Copyright 2020 Christine Flowers. Flowers is an attorney and a columnist for the Delaware County Daily Times, and can be reached at cflowers1961@gmail.com.

Tags

(6) comments

Vtrone

The question that needs to be asked of the ed. writer Christine Flowers and disabled paraplegic republican candidate Madison Cawthorne is why are they supporting republican presidential candidate Donald Trump? When in Nov. 24, 2015 at the Myrtle Beach Convention Center, South Carolina, in front of millions of television viewers and hundreds of his cheering republican supporters, Donald Trump proceeded to mock, make fun of and imitate disabled news reporter Serge Kovaleski? Who in fact, suffers from arthrogryposis, a disease that limits functions of the joints. Unfortunately, what made it so sad, inconsiderate and mean was that while Trump was mocking the disabled reporter by waving his arms aimlessly all over, his republican supporters cheered him on. Christine Flowers writes of Yamiche Alcindor: "How dare she use someone else's misfortune to advance a political agenda, and do so in a way that is dishonestly veiled." I guess Ms. Flowers prefers the Trump way of openly mocking the disabled in front of an audience of millions to advance his political agenda.

phxnative54

Vtrone: Point well made. It's interesting to note that Ms. Flowers admires Madison Cawthorn so much that she couldn't even be bothered to spell his name correctly. (Yet Ms. Alcindor does spell it correctly in the tweet that Ms. Flowers quotes.)

marymiller08

Well said, thank you.

georgem

Kudos For Highlighting this BRAVE YOUNG MAN 🙏🙌👍💪👏🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸 GOD BLESS him and ALL...THAT HE "STOOD" FOR ...And THANK HIM

charlie

Thank you for posting this story and georgems response. With the November elections closing in, it seems like the FEW DEMOCRATS in the area have been coming out of the woodwork to bad mouth our President.

Vtrone

Charlie, when your republican president bad mouths hundreds of people, intelligence agencies, and even ex-members of his own administration, he opens the door for others to do the same to him. Ironically, he will never bad mouth his idol Putin, even when Putin put a bounty for every American soldier killed. Moreover, your Fascist President Trump is right now bad mouthing our veterans and our U.S. troops who served and are serving our country as "suckers" and those that were killed fighting for our country,freedoms,liberties, he bad mouths as "Losers." The 64,000 dollar question is,"What happened to the republican party that used to have principles, integrity, Patriotism, morality and enough brains not to be led astray by a Fascist Demagogue.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.