In 1998 the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service turned the first Mexican grey wolves into the wild in the Blue Range Primitive Area of eastern Arizona. Their recovery goal is “to conserve and protect the Mexican grey wolf and its habitat so that its long term survival is secured, populations are capable of enduring threats and it can be removed from the list of threatened and endangered species.”

The cause sounds noble and upon first glance, it gives the appearance that the Mexican grey wolf primitively had a very robust and established population. In reality, the historical evidence of a thriving, large wolf population in Arizona and New Mexico may be as grey as the wolf itself.

The Endangered Species Act has over-stepped its bounds. How does it trump all other constitutional rights including property rights, state rights and personal rights? This recovery process has been non-transparent and undemocratic. Unelected officials from an administrative body are creating and pushing a program that neither Congress nor a judicial body ever mandated. No American citizens ever voted for a wolf recovery. These unelected officials remain faceless and nameless and pose a huge threat to our Western heritage and essentially our American freedom.

in Arizona and New Mexico, rural citizens are under attack. Freedoms, rights and opportunities they once enjoyed in the rural sector are being stripped away. The American cowboy is the endangered species, and nowhere is there an act to conserve and protect him. Many small family ranches in the Southwest are being overwhelmed with wolf presence. What started out as an occasional incident has become weekly depredation and slaughter. Over the last three years the number of confirmed wolf kills on livestock (cattle & horses) has been increasing at over 60% annually. At this rate, neither cattle nor wildlife can sustain healthy balance.

On May 17, dozens of local citizens from Apache and Greenlee counties and many from neighboring New Mexico counties united and rode horseback into Alpine, Arizona. They met in the same building where 20 years ago a public meeting was held regarding the concerns of the new wolf recovery program. Now many of the same people who attended the first meeting, returned to discuss the much needed change. The same concerns that previously existed now are backed with two decades of economic loss, looming human danger and negative experience with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. Ranchers, outfitters, local business owners and rural citizens met to discuss a resolution they hope will initiate change. The economic impact of the recovery program is crippling these already struggling counties. Apache County, Arizona and Catron County, New Mexico are amongst the poorest counties in the country. As wolf numbers grow, so to will the financial impact on families and communities who reside in the recovery area.

H. Jay Platt lives in Catron County New Mexico.

H. Jay Platt lives in Catron County New Mexico.

(4) comments

ronzim reports as of Jan 2019 that the reintroduction of wolves in Yellowstone has resulted in a massive cascade of benefits which have caused an ecological resurrection in the park. The number of beaver colonies has increased by 900%(from one to nine); the introduction of the wolves kept up predatory pressure on the elk and they had little time to browse and destroy young Willows. As a result, the park now abounds with a health Willow population. The Elk have benefitted too by herd reduction to a size which is sustainable in the park.

The large increase in beaver dams has had a remarkable effect of stream hydrology, increasing fish stock, replenishing underground water supplies and attracting new song birds to the larger stands of Willows. Park scientists say it will take many years to fully appreciate the benefits of the increased wolf population. The combined land masses of Arizona and New Mexico is 233,366 square miles. That is about one wolf for every 2000 square miles(or about one pack per every 14,00 square miles). The author fails to mention the compensation that livestock owners are paid due to wolf predation, which now averages about $1000 from the FEDS, and to which must be added an additional payment from the Co-existence Council.

Finally, in 2015(data change little over time) almost half of all cattle predation deaths in the U.S. were by coyotes. Dogs, at about 12% of all such deaths, outrank wolves whose total is trivial.

The fact is that most ranchers are learning to live(on the land that we the people rent to them)with predation.


Agree with all of ronzim's comments and must add that wolves also "cull" the weakest and sickest if/when they do kill elk or deer--thus they are bringing back beneficial natural ecological balancing to wildlife species. Wolves are not killing the biggest and genetically best to hang on their den walls (and thus weakening the species). A HSUS in-depth, nation-wide research showed that predation of livestock by wolves is way at the bottom of the scale--extremely minimal.



Bob Smith

Get the cows off our public lands and the problem goes away. If cowpunching is becoming an endangered profession then let it die - that's what capitalism is all about: your business thrives or dies based on the market. Sorry sir you may have to get a job doing something other than what your father did; happens to people every day.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.