Forest Service investigating two horses found shot near Heber-Overgaard (copy)

Horses from the Heber herd. Approximately 272 free-roaming horses live in the Apache-Sitgreaves National Forests east of Heber on the south side of SR260.

The Heber Wild Horses Freedom Preservation Alliance is a grassroots group that advocates to keep the Heber herd in the wild and protected as is mandated by federal law. Being boots on the ground in the forest, keeping track of the horses and documenting the bands are some of the numerous functions that we do.

Our team discovered several of the horses that had been fatally shot during the shooting spree last January.

Our team went out to every horse that was found dead. We took photos, videos and logged into our records every horse that fell victim. Bullet holes were apparent in several horses. We compiled a timeline which included the responses of the USFS law enforcement and the Navajo County Sheriff’s Department. We saw no indication of an immediate investigative process taking place by USDA Forest Service Law Enforcement officers.

In our opinion the investigative response was slow and lackadaisical. More recently an eye witness account was called in regarding a man shooting at wild horses. The Forest Service never even bothered to go out to the scene to interview the eyewitness or suspect.

On January 22, 2019 the Sheriff’s Department notified us that a black stallion was found dead. A dead bay mare found in close proximity. The stallion was a wild horse called Raven. We saw what appeared to be a bullet hole in Raven’s head and a shattered leg bone that could have resulted from having been shot. Forest Service Law Enforcement Officer John Lopez was at the scene. His investigation consisted of turning over Raven’s body. The bay mare was looked at by a Forest Service Law Enforcement Officer, but there was no real investigation done on her at that time.

A citizen told us that Officer Lopez mentioned a veterinarian was going to be out to do a necropsy on the two horses. Two of our people stayed with the bodies until dusk to keep predators away. No veterinarian came.

Over the days that passed our team continued to monitor the roads and carcasses. More dead horses were found that appeared to have been shot at the same time as Raven and the mare. Eight days after Raven and the mare were found shot, with no further inspection being done on the horses by the Forest Service, one of our team called Officer Lopez and left a detailed voice mail asking for permission to bring our own veterinarian to do necropsies. The next day Officer Lopez advised our team member that he was bringing in a veterinarian to do necropsies the following day.

The next day necropsies were done. It was officially determined that many of the horses had been shot including the black stallion, Raven. Some bodies were too decomposed to be able to determine the cause of death. It was 10 days after Raven’s body had been discovered before the Forest Service had a veterinarian perform necropsies.

Mary Hauser is a Heber Wild Horses Freedom Preservation Alliance Team Member

Mary Hauser is a Heber Wild Horses Freedom Preservation Alliance Team Member

(2) comments


You know, when you are a part of a collaborative group to figure this mess out, and you draw lines in the sand and refuse to actually collaborate (and later get dis-invited due to the intolerance for ANY sort of compromise), well, perhaps this is the result. People whose livelihoods are at stake (ranchers for one), recreationists, wildlife (real wildlife, not feral animals like these horses) enthusiasts, hunters, etc. etc. are willing to come to the table to figure out how to best live with these non-native animals, but you won't stand for a one single management action. I for one put the deaths of these feral horses on the "wild horse lovers" right on you for your lack of compromise and willingness to embrace some sort of collaboration with others who have equal, if not greater, stake in the forest resources. This is what you get.

Louie C

More to the truth..CORPORATE PROFITS at stake

Posted on Straight from the Horse's Heart

June 8, 2015

June 8, 2015

Cattle Rancher Calls for Adoption, Euthanasia, or Slaughter of the Heber Wild Horse Herd

The Rest of the Story

Rancher Larry Gibson works for the Seibert Cattle Company LLC which has federal lands grazing leases in several states.  Gibson runs Seibert cattle on the Heber Grazing Allotment where many of the Heber wild horses live.  Part of the grazing allotment covers nearly half of the dedicated Heber Wild Horse Territory in the Apache-Sitgreaves National Forests in Arizona.

Gibson claims the wild horse population has increased exponentially over the years.  However, the last two USFS aerial counts from 2014 and 2015 show the population of the herd in and around the Heber Wild Horse Territory to be approximately 202, which is down over 100 horses from 2005 when a previous wild horse roundup was stopped by a court order.  According to USFS the total 2015 count for the entire 2.7 million acre Apache-Sitgreaves Forests was 320.

The Heber grazing allotment renewal EA coincidentally was just recently released and calls for increasing the amount of cattle to be grazed.  This grazing allotment calls for structural and non-structural improvements costing approximately $4 million dollars without saying how much of that economic burden will be placed on the American tax payer.  Public comments are now open through Friday, June 12, 2015.

Please take a look at the Heber Allotment Draft Environmental Assessment

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.